What is the relationship between the minister, who has legal responsib
ility for a department and the secretary the permanent principal offic
er, in a parliamentary system? Joseph F. Zimmerman reviewed the litera
ture and interviewed sitting and retired secretaries and former minist
ers in the Republic of Ireland. Employing four models, the author exam
ines the legal and informal relationships that exist between a ministe
r and a secretary and the political culture within which they operate.
The changing roles of the secretary and the impact of the Top-Level A
ppointments Committee are analyzed with particular emphasis on the pol
icy advice role of the secretary. The author concludes that the policy
advice rot has declined; the secretary is primarily a coordinator of
the activities of the various divisions within the department, and a c
ooperation model explains the relationship between a minister and a se
cretary.