Ee. Castilla et al., THE FREQUENCY AND SPECTRUM OF CONGENITAL-ANOMALIES IN NATURAL FAMILY-PLANNING USERS IN SOUTH-AMERICA - NO INCREASE IN A CASE-CONTROL STUDY, Advances in contraception, 13(4), 1997, pp. 395-404
Users of natural family planning (NFP) practice periodic abstinence, l
eading many to reason that such couples should show increased anomalie
s in offspring as a result of fertilization involving aging gametes. I
n an effort to complement our NFP cohort study, we currently conducted
a case-control study in the same region (South America) in which the
largest number of cases have been recruited for our cohort NFP study.
During 1992-94, 5324 case-control pairs of mothers were interviewed du
ring the immediate postpartum period in 18 maternity hospitals partici
pating in the Latin-American Collaborative Study of Congenital Malform
ations: ECLAMC (Spanish acronym for Latin-American Collaborative Study
of Congenital Malformations). Natural family planning (NFP) usage was
recorded in 6% of mothers in the ECLAMC sample studied (n = 10 648).
Overall, no significant differences in frequency of NFP usage were obs
erved between malformed cases (349/5324 = 6.6%) and normal controls (3
03/5324 = 5.7%) (chi(2) = 3.3; df = 1; p > 0.05). No significant diffe
rences in sex ratios were observed between children of NFP user and no
n-user mothers. Of special interest is the lack of association between
NFP and Down syndrome, the sentinel phenotype for the hypothesis of d
elayed fertilization (aging gametes).