J. Nicholl et J. Turner, EFFECTIVENESS OF A REGIONAL TRAUMA SYSTEM IN REDUCING MORTALITY FROM MAJOR TRAUMA - BEFORE AND AFTER STUDY, BMJ. British medical journal, 315(7119), 1997, pp. 1349-1354
Objective: To assess the effect of the development of an experimental
trauma centre and regional trauma system on the survival of patients w
ith major trauma. Design: Controlled before and after study examining
outcomes between 1990 and 1993, spanning the introduction of the syste
m in 1991-2. Setting: Trauma centre in North Staffordshire Royal Infir
mary and five associated district general hospitals in the North West
Midlands regional trauma system, and two control regions in Lancashire
and Humberside. Subjects: All trauma patients taken by the ambulance
services serving the regions or arriving other than by ambulance with
injury severity scores > 15, whether or not they had vital signs on ar
rival at hospital. Main outcome measures: Survival rates standardised
for age, severity of injury, and revised trauma score. Results: In 199
0, 33% of major trauma patients in the experimental region were taken
to the trauma centre, and by 1993 this had risen to only 39%, Crude de
ath rates changed by the same amount in the control regions (46.5% in
1990-1 to 44.4% in 1992-3) as in the experimental region (44.8% to 41.
3%), After standardisation, the estimated change in the probability of
dying in the experimental region compared with the control regions wa
s -0.8% per year (95% confidence interval -3.6% to 2.2%); for out of h
ours care, the change was 1.6% per year (-2.3% to 5.6%), and, for mult
iply injured patients, the change was -1.6% (-6.1% to 2.6%). Conclusio
n: Any reductions in mortality from regionalising major trauma care in
shire areas of England would probably be modest compared with reports
fr om the United States.