Yz. Wang et al., 2ND-ORDER MOTION PERCEPTION IN PERIPHERAL-VISION - LIMITS OF EARLY FILTERING, Journal of the Optical Society of America. A, Optics, image science,and vision., 14(12), 1997, pp. 3145-3154
Spatial and temporal analysis of contrast-modulated sine-wave gratings
reveals that the second-order motion stimulus contains two sidebands,
with equal energy but moving in opposite directions, flanking a stati
onary carrier. Any early linear spatial filtering process in the visua
l system that attenuates one sideband more than the other will be detr
imental to the balance between the two sidebands, so that the perceive
d direction of the carrier might be opposite to that of the envelope m
otion. We tested this hypothesis by using contrast-modulated gratings
presented centrally or at 20 deg in the horizontal nasal field with a
two-alternative forced-choice staircase paradigm. We found that when t
he envelope frequency was close to that of the carrier, a second-order
stimulus whose envelope motion direction was correctly identified in
the fovea appeared to drift in the opposite direction in the periphery
. Further increasing the envelope spatial frequency resulted in a reve
rsed motion percept in bath central and peripheral viewing conditions.
For subjects to identify correctly the direction of motion of the env
elope, the spatial frequency ratio of the carrier to the envelope had
to be more than 2 in the fovea and more than 6 in the periphery. These
phenomena in second-order motion perception can be explained by a lin
ear model of motion detection with an early spatial filtering process.
Further experiments and computer simulation show that undersampling o
f the carrier has Little effect on second-order motion perception in t
he periphery, as long as the carrier is detectable. (C) 1997 Optical S
ociety of America.