My. Song et al., COMPARATIVE TOXICITY OF 4 INSECTICIDES, INCLUDING IMIDACLOPRID AND TEBUFENOZIDE, TO 4 AQUATIC ARTHROPODS, Environmental toxicology and chemistry, 16(12), 1997, pp. 2494-2500
The tolerance of four aquatic organisms to four chemicals (aldicarb, d
imethoate, imidacloprid, and tebufenozide) was determined using 48-h a
cute toxicity tests at 27 degrees C. Species included two saline (Arte
mia sp. and Aedes taeniorhynchus (Wiedemann)) and two freshwater (Daph
nia magna Straus and Aedes aegypti (L.)) organisms. Temperature was al
so evaluated as a toxicity modifying factor for the freshwater species
. Two selective insecticides (imidacloprid and tebufenozide) were comp
ared with two broad-spectrum insecticides, aldicarb and dimethoate. In
general, A. taeniorhynchus was the most susceptible, and Artemia sp.
was the most tolerant to insecticides used under our experimental cond
itions. Both aldicarb and dimethoate caused neurotoxicity in all organ
isms tested. Mortality associated with molting suggested that tebufeno
zide affected the molting process of all organisms, causing the format
ion of an incompletely sclerotized head capsule and the failure of ecd
ysis in the mosquito species. These responses resulted in lethal larva
l molts. Imidacloprid, on the other hand, caused delayed symptoms of g
eneral nerve poisoning compared with the two acetylcholine esterase in
hibitors. Our results suggest that both tebufenozide and imidacloprid
would be selective insecticides that can be used with reasonable envir
onmental safety toward nontarget aquatic crustaceans. There was a grea
ter correlation of susceptibility to test chemicals within taxonomical
ly close organisms than between organisms that share habitats.