Rb. Goldstein et al., FAMILIAL AGGREGATION AND PHENOMENOLOGY OF EARLY-ONSET (AT OR BEFORE AGE 20 YEARS) PANIC DISORDER, Archives of general psychiatry, 54(3), 1997, pp. 271-278
Background: While early age at onset has been associated with increase
d familial risk, increased clinical severity, and distinctive patterns
of comorbidity in a range of psychiatric disorders, it has received l
imited attention in panic disorder, both in family studies and with re
spect to clinical presentation. Methods: A family study of 838 adult f
irst-degree relatives of 152 probands in 3 diagnostic groups (panic di
sorder with or without major depression, subdivided by age at onset at
or before 20 and after 20 years, and screened normal controls) was us
ed to examine familial aggregation of panic disorder by proband age at
panic disorder onset. Phenomenology of panic disorder in ill probands
and their affected adult first-degree relatives was investigated as a
function of proband panic disorder onset at or before 20 vs after 20
years of age. Results: Compared with adult first-degree relatives of n
ormal controls, the risks of panic disorder in adult first-degree rela
tives of probands with panic disorder onset at or before 20 and after
20 years of age were increased 17-fold and 6-fold, respectively. These
findings were not explained by the numerous potential confounding fac
tors that we tested. Age at panic disorder onset did not appear to be
specifically transmitted within families. The clinical presentation of
panic disorder differed little in either probands or affected relativ
es by proband age at onset. Conclusion: The strikingly elevated risk o
f panic disorder in relatives of probands with panic disorder onset at
or before 20 years of age suggests that age at onset may be useful in
differentiating familial subtypes of panic disorder and that genetic
studies of panic disorder should consider age at onset.