When a memory test is unexpected, recall performance is quite poor at
retention intervals as short as 2-4 seconds. Orienting tasks that chan
ge encoding conditions are known to affect forgetting in such ''very r
apid forgetting'' paradigms where people are misled to believe that re
call will not be required. We evaluated the hypothesis that difference
s in forgetting among orienting tasks are attributable to contribution
s of secondary memory during encoding in two experiments. In Experimen
t 1, short-term recall performance was inversely related to task deman
ds during encoding, although long-term memory performance was not. Tas
k demands were assessed by making the duration of stimulus presentatio
n dependent on the time required to perform three different orienting
tasks. In Experiment 2, we compared performance of that variable-lengt
h stimulus presentation to the fixed-length presentation used in most
prior research. The results suggested that additional encoding or rehe
arsal time does not have an appreciable impact on short-term performan
ce. Thus, differences in forgetting appeared to be a function of the c
ontribution of secondary memory rather than a function of the time ava
ilable to engage in primary memory rehearsal strategies.