Y. Bedard et al., SOIL COMPACTION BY MANURE SPREADERS EQUIPPED WITH STANDARD AND OVERSIZED TIRES AND MULTIPLE AXLES, Transactions of the ASAE, 40(1), 1997, pp. 37-43
A study was conducted on a heavy clay soil to evaluate soil compaction
induced by different traffic treatments associated with liquid manure
spreader systems. Five spreader weights (from 96 to 218 kN), two runn
ing gears (tandem and tridem, i.e., three axles) and two types of tire
(conventional low section tire and oversized tire) were combined to o
btain six traffic treatments, representative of liquid manure spreadin
g operations in Quebec. Soil dry bulk density (rho(b)) and cone index
(CI) were measured to evaluate compaction. Tire rut depths and the lat
eral influence zone were also investigated in the study. For a single
pass of a spreader soil compaction was confined to the tilled layer (a
bout 0-250 mm depth) regardless of traffic treatments, and this did no
t affect emergence rates and yields of soybean under the particular so
il and climate conditions that prevailed at the time of the study. Nei
ther tandem nor tridem running gears were found to adequately contain
soil compaction within the tilled layer for total spreader weights exc
eeding 154 kN. The acceptable limitation for a tandem spreader with co
nventional 21.5L-16.1 tires would be a total load of about 96 kN, resu
lting in average ground pressures of 150 kPa or less. If medium capaci
ty spreaders are required, oversized tires are recommended for manure
spreading on prairies or post-seeding applications on small grain crop
s. Finally, the recourse to multiple-axle running gears for larger spr
eaders to maintain or reduce unit load per axle or ground pressure doe
s not result in less soil compaction than lower capacity tandem spread
ers with comparable axle loads and ground pressure.