G. Lesec et al., THE P53-POSITIVE PHENOTYPE OF BREAST CANCERS - CORRELATION WITH OTHERPARAMETERS AND CONSEQUENCES ON ITS BIOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE, International journal of oncology, 10(4), 1997, pp. 747-752
One hundred and eighty-one breast cancer specimens were analyzed for n
uclear p53 staining by immunochemical methods. There were 123 fine-nee
dle cytological specimens and 58 frozen tissue sections of surgical bi
opsies. The microscopic evaluation of the staining fitted with a 4 gro
up classification. Ninety-one samples (50.6%) were devoid of any stain
ing (-), while 42 (23.3%) showed only few stained nuclei (+/-), typica
lly around 1%. Thirty-two (17.8%) samples presented with strong nuclea
r staining (++) which in practically all cases concerned more than 50%
of the nuclei, but a few cases showed staining heterogeneity. A furth
er 17 cases (9.4%) presented with nuclear staining which concerned 10-
20% of the cancer cells (+). This four class system was used to compar
e p53 expression with other prognostic parameters. A strong inverse co
rrelation was observed with steroid hormone receptor content and p53 p
ositivity was highly significantly associated with higher S-phase. All
but one of the highly positive cases were aneuploid. Twenty-five perc
ent (29/120) of the aneuploid tumors were strongly stained and a furth
er 10% were considered positive (+). On the other hand, only 5 out of
59 DNA-diploid tumors were considered as + and one ++. The DNA index d
istribution according to p53 positivity showed peaks of positivity for
hypodiploid, triploid and hypertetraploid values. Negative tumors wer
e in all regards similar to those with only few stained nuclei, in par
ticular mean S-phases of 2.8 and 3.3% respectively. Altogether, the ty
pical strong p53 phenotype concerned a DNA-aneuploid tumor with above
median S-phase fraction (mean of 7.1%), negative steroid hormone recep
tors and cytoprognostic index III. The p53 positive cases (+), were fr
equently steroid hormone receptor positive and had on the average inte
rmediate S-phase fractions (4.3%). The proportion of immunochemical po
sitivity (27% in our series), is compatible with the published frequen
cy of p53 mutations detected in breast cancers, but the differences in
the phenotype according to the level of positivity should be further
investigated.