Increased investment in reproduction during current breeding event may
entail future fitness costs. Even though a wide array of both theoret
ical and empirical work; has been devoted to solve the problem of opti
mal reproductive rate, evidence for costs of reproduction has been equ
ivocal. In the present study we examined the survival of pied flycatch
er parents after a clutch size manipulation where we altered clutch si
ze with one or two eggs. We monitored return rates and dispersal of pa
rents during subsequent years after manipulation An artificial increas
e in reproductive effort caused lowered return rates of males. Results
on breeding dispersal did not support the explanation that observed l
ow return rate was due to differences in dispersal. Thus, it seemed th
at low return rate of males with increased reproductive effort was due
to lower local survival. No survival cost on females was evident, but
return rate of females was tao low for a proper test. An analysis on
reproductive success revealed that within treatment groups the returni
ng males tended to be more successful in their previous reproductive e
vent than non-returning ones. These results together imply that phenot
ypic quality of individuals varies considerably causing fitness differ
ences between individuals.