Ec. Poulin et R. Labbe, FULLY THORACOSCOPIC PULMONARY LOBECTOMY AND SPECIMEN EXTRACTION THROUGH RIB SEGMENT RESECTION - PRELIMINARY-REPORT, Surgical endoscopy, 11(4), 1997, pp. 354-358
Background: A technique of fully thoracoscopic pulmonary lobectomy wit
h rib-segment resection for specimen extraction is described, and prel
iminary results in 18 patients are presented. Methods: Surgery is perf
ormed through four 15-mm ports. For all lobes except one, the surgeon
operates in front of the patient, where the rib spaces are widest and
rib-space trauma is less, When lobar dissection is complete, specimen
extraction is performed after resection of a rib segment proportional
to tumor size. Muscle section is kept to a minimum. There is no rib re
traction. Results: There were no deaths, three conversions to open sur
gery, and three major complications. Average postoperative stay was 5.
4 days for patients without complications and 9.6 days for patients wi
th complications, In total six patients presented with some degree of
air leaks, and two had post-thoracotomy pain (>2 month's duration). Th
e literature is reviewed to analyze current techniques and to define p
arameters of a truly minimally invasive pulmonary lobectomy. Conclusio
ns: This technique is safe and promising; however, thoracoscopic lobec
tomy still needs refining. Before valid randomized studies comparing t
horacoscopic lobectomy and muscle-sparing thoracotomy or posterolatera
l thoracotomy can be credible, technical issues related to the product
ion of a truly minimally invasive procedure should be resolved.