The Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement (FTA) was expected to reallocate
workers from high-cost firms to low-cost firms, thus promoting special
ization and trade creation. Instead, employment contracted across all
industries during 1989-93 and real exports and imports contracted over
most of the period. This trade destruction provides some evidence tha
t the massive 1989-93 Canadian job losses were not primarily caused by
the FTA. We further show that FTA tariff cuts account for no more tha
n 15 per cent of the Canadian job losses. Restated, other factors (inc
luding the fight against inflation) explain more than 85 per cent of t
he job losses.