The marginal political costs of different types of taxes and governmen
t spending, as well as voter preferences over different fiscal variabl
es, are examined using two different specifications for political cost
- one based on the probability of incumbent defeat and the other base
d on the incumbent's percentage of the vote. Models associated with th
ese two specifications, in which voting behaviour depends on disaggreg
ated taxes and government expenditures, are estimated using data from
Canadian provincial elections. The empirical results, which indicate t
hat different types of taxes and expenditures have quite different mar
ginal political costs, have important implications for models that inc
orporate voter preferences.