Re. Dales et al., INDOOR AIR-QUALITY AND HEALTH - VALIDITY AND DETERMINANTS OF REPORTEDHOME DAMPNESS AND MOLDS, International journal of epidemiology, 26(1), 1997, pp. 120-125
Background. Questionnaire-based surveys from several countries have co
nsistently detected adverse health associated with home dampness and m
ould growth. Methods. To test the validity of questions commonly used
to indicate the presence of indoor mould, questionnaires were administ
ered in 403 homes where dust samples were taken for viable fungi and a
ir samples for ergosterol. Results. Geometric mean concentrations of t
he total viable fungi were 255 (SE 116) x 10(3) CFU/g when mouldy odou
rs were reported and 155 (SE 55) when odours were not reported (P = 0.
01). Similarly, reported water damage was associated with a 50% increa
se (P = 0.06). Geometric mean concentrations of the predominantly indo
or-source fungi, Aspergillus plus Penicillium, were twice as high when
mould or mildew was reported than when not mentioned (P = 0.01). The
presence of reported mould or water damage was unrelated to the presen
ce of detectable levels of ergosterol. There was evidence for reportin
g bias: in the presence of low concentrations of viable fungi in dust,
respondents reporting allergies were more likely to report visible mo
uld growth (odds ratio [OR] = 1.8, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.9-3
.5, P = 0.10. In the presence of elevated concentrations of dust fungi
, respondents who smoked were less likely to report visible mould grow
th, (OR = 0.4, 95% CI : 0.2-0.7, P = 0.005). Conclusions. Reported mou
ld, water damage, and mouldy odours were associated with elevated leve
ls of indoor fungi. However, inaccuracy was high and there was evidenc
e of a systematic reporting bias. Future research should concentrate o
n developing accurate objective measures of exposure to fungi, and the
n use this information to develop valid questionnaires. Currently, obj
ective measures, not questionnaires, are recommended to clarify the he
alth effects of indoor fungi.