Much work has been published on methods for assessing the probable num
ber of clusters or structures within unknown data sets. This paper aim
s to look in more detail at two methods, a broad parametric method, ba
sed around the assumption of Gaussian clusters and the other a non-par
ametric method which utilises methods of scale-space filtering to extr
act robust structures within a data set. It is shown that, whilst both
methods are capable of determining cluster validity for data sets in
which clusters tend towards a multivariate Gaussian distribution, the
parametric method inevitably fails for clusters which have a non-Gauss
ian structure whilst the scale-space method is more robust. Copyright
(C) 1997 Pattern Recognition Society.