Given that ethnic identity in the form of caste and religion is not li
kely to disappear from national politics, the key question is whether
ethnic mobilisation carl be successfully separated from ethnic polaris
ation. The last Vidhan Sabha elections in Uttar Pradesh present a case
where political parries attempted precisely this separation. Although
each political party constructed the electorate as a collection of et
hnic blocs, and sought to expand its vote share by targeting certain b
locs and ignoring others, the identification of the ethnic 'other' tha
t has in the last few years proved a highly successful strategy in UP
politics was conspicuously absent. Understanding the considerations th
at led to this shift in UP may prove useful in illuminating the possib
le ways in which caste and religion may affect the trajectory of India
n politics at the national level. This article argues that, unfortunat
ely, the conditions that led to the moderation of political party beha
viour in UP are not stable. An analysis of the election strategies of
each of the principal parties or groups of parties reveals that for al
l parties, except the Congress, the incentives towards moderation were
a product of immediate circumstances that are likely, to change, rath
er thaw structural conditions that can be expected to endure.