T. Shirakawa et K. Morimoto, INTERPLAY OF CIGARETTE-SMOKING AND OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE ON SPECIFIC IMMUNOGLOBULIN-E ANTIBODIES TO COBALT, Archives of environmental health, 52(2), 1997, pp. 124-128
The results of a cross-sectional survey of an occupational population
(n = 706) exposed to hard metal dust revealed distribution of specific
immunoglobulin E antibodies against cobalt-conjugated serum albumin (
Co-HSA). This population was segregated with respect to smoking and du
st-exposure doses. Standard deviations (0.08-0.13) of Co-HSA RAST were
sufficiently small (< 7%) to warrant reproductibility. Confirming evi
dence for 8 workers who had mean + 3 standard deviations of Co-HSA RAS
T indices and who had been diagnosed with occupational asthma also pro
vided better sensitivity (8/19) and specificity (687/687) of hard meta
l asthma, rather than metal-induced asthma. Cobalt exposure resulted i
n significant increases in Co-HSA RAST indices in males, whose mean in
dex was 1.16 +/- 0.13 in nonexposed subjects and 1.37 +/- 0.13 in expo
sed subjects. There was no difference, however, in the females. This d
ifference between males and females cannot be explained by differences
in ages or dust-exposure doses. Furthermore, the specific RAST indice
s against Co-HSA displayed a strong correlation not only to the intens
ity of cobalt exposure (r =.488, p <.001), but to log(total exposure d
oses) (r =.578, p <.001). These results suggest that Co-HSA RAST might
be useful as a biological marker for the allergic etiology of hard me
tal asthma. Nonexposed smokers had similar mean RAST indices: 1.18 +/-
0.12 IU/ml, compared with 1.15 +/- 0.16 IU/ml for nonexposed subjects
who had never smoked. There was no correlation between Brinkman indic
es (i.e., number of cigarettes/d x y) and RAST indices in any of the m
ale groups. Higher, but not significant, mean RAST indices were found
for ex-smokers in both the nonexposed (1.18 +/- 0.14) and exposed subj
ects (1.26 +/- 0.12), compared with subjects who had never smoked. Ser
um immunoglobulin E levels in the ex-smokers declined with age after t
hey quit smoking, irrespective of exposure status. In contrast, hard m
etal (cobalt) exposure elevated specific immunoglobulin E. The results
of the study suggest that elimination of hard dust exposure is more i
mportant than cessation of smoking in the minimization of risk of bron
chial asthma. Hard metal exposure may be a preventable risk factor for
occupational asthma.