Am. Shenoy et al., FUNCTIONAL UTILITY AND ONCOLOGIC SAFETY OF NEAR-TOTAL LARYNGECTOMY WITH TRACHEOPHARYNGEAL SPEECH SHUNT IN A THIRD-WORLD ONCOLOGIC CENTER, European archives of oto-rhino-laryngology, 254(3), 1997, pp. 128-132
This prospective study analyzes the feasibility, oncologic safety and
functional utility of Pearson's near-total laryngectomy with tracheoph
aryngeal shunt (NTL-TPSS). The procedure was found to give gratifying
locoregional control in 30 consecutive advanced T3 and selected T4 tum
ors involving the larynx (n = 11) and hypopharynx (n = 19) and managed
at Kidwai Memorial Institute of Oncology, Bangalore, India. The oncol
ogic ''safety'' of this technique was established in following examina
tions, ranging from 18 to 44 months (median, 22.2 months). A locoregio
nal control rate of 74% was obtained. Lung-powered ''shunt'' speech wa
s acquired with ease in periods ranging from 7 days in speakers deemed
''excellent'' (15/29) to 20 days in those deemed ''satisfactory'' (8/
29). Except for a single case experiencing temporary aspiration of liq
uids, patients did not have any swallowing difficulties following remo
val of nasogastric tubes. The period of hospitalization averaged 22.6
days. The complication rate was 33%, with one patient death (3.3%) occ
urring. The dynamics of the TPSS were analyzed in selected ''speakers'
' and ''non-speakers'', using transcutaneous needle electromyography.
Analysis of data supports the possibility of dynamic speech modulation
. However, the favored anatomic location and design renders the shunts
aspiration-proof rather than demonstrating any active sphincteric act
ion.