Stratospheric NOy profiles from the Garcia-Solomon two-dimensional mod
el are compared to observed profiles from the Upper Atmosphere Researc
h Satellite (UARS) and the Atmospheric Trace Molecule Spectroscopy Exp
eriment (ATMOS). The model consistently overestimates NOy in the upper
stratosphere beyond the range of uncertainty in the satellite data. T
he relatively short lifetime of NOy in this region suggests a largely
photochemical explanation for the discrepancy. Uncertainties in the ph
otochemical production of NOy from N2O strongly influence stratospheri
c NOy profiles, but this influence decreases with increasing height in
the upper stratosphere. Photochemical loss of NO is controlled by the
NO photolysis rate and the reaction rates of N + NO and N + O-2. All
these rates are subject to substantial uncertainties that probably con
tribute to the discrepancy between model and observations.