The proper means of measuring quality of life in chronically ill patie
nts is unclear. Because different measures may assess varied aspects o
f patients' experience and because they may be interrelated in differe
nt ways, the relationship between several of these quality-of-life mea
sures, including indices of psychological well-being, social support,
and severity of illness in ESRD patients treated with hemodialysis (HD
), was prospectively assessed. In addition, it was determined whether
patients' assessment of quality of life, along any dimension, was rela
ted to patient compliance in three urban HD units, in a population lar
gely composed of African-American patients. Severity of illness scores
correlated with both attendance and compliance with the dialysis pres
cription. Karnofsky scores correlated inversely with age, depression,
social environment, and level of severity of illness, as expected, but
not with behavioral compliance measures. Social support scores correl
ated with perception of illness, depression, satisfaction with life, a
nd adjustment to illness scores, but not with behavioral or standard c
ompliance measures. Perception of illness scores correlated with depre
ssion, social support, adjustment to illness, and satisfaction with li
fe scores, but not with Karnofsky ratings, severity scores, or standar
d and/or behavioral compliance measures. Social environment scores cor
related with almost all assessed variables, with the exception of anth
ropometric measurements, predialysis phosphorus levels, and behavioral
compliance measures. Satisfaction with life scores (a global, subject
ive measure of quality of life) correlated with advancing age, level o
f social support, severity of illness, and the presence of a relations
hip, but were not correlated with Karnofsky scores. These data suggest
that quality of life in patients treated with HD must be measured in
several ways. The Psychological Adjustment to Illness Scale Social Env
ironment score may be a useful, generalizable adjunct measure of quali
ty of life in HD patients, in addition to the Satisfaction With Life S
cale. Quality of life and perception of the effects of illness are not
necessarily associated with functional ability in HD patients. These
findings must be considered where making decisions about the discontin
uation of HD treatment.