In an attempt to determine the best indications for the classically ad
opted ileo-rectal anastomosis (IRA) and the new techniques of restorat
ive proctocolectomy, namely, ileal J-pouch-anal anastomosis (IAA) and
ileal J-pouch-anal canal anastomosis (IACA), we retrospectively studie
d 72 surgically treated patients with ulcerative colitis (UC) followed
in our surgical department in the period between 1963 and 1994. Compa
red to these new techniques, IRA had a lower incidence of postoperativ
e fecal incontinence, and was one-stepped in the majority of the patie
nts. No significant difference regarding postoperative bowel function,
operation time, volume of bleeding, hospital stay, and the need for p
ostoperative prednisolone was observed. We concluded that IRA is a goo
d procedure that is indicated for patients receiving high-dose prednis
olone, for those who need a quick return to social activity, and for t
hose with poor anal function. IACA is a good indication for those pati
ents with good anal function assessed preoperatively, who agree to rec
eive a multi-step operation. For those patients with cancer or dysplas
ia, IAA should be the operation of first choice.