PURPOSE: To evaluate Doppler ultrasound (US) as a screening modality b
efore arteriography for extracranial carotid artery disease. MATERIALS
AND METHODS: The net benefit in stroke reduction from screening with
Doppler US was calculated on the basis of literature estimates of dise
ase prevalence, risk reduction data, and locally validated sensitiviti
es and specificities for detection of carotid artery stenosis and occl
usion in 215 patients. RESULTS: Screening a symptomatic population dem
onstrated a net stroke reduction. Screening asymptomatic populations w
ith a 20% prevalence of greater than or equal to 60% stenosis also yie
lded a net stroke reduction. Screening low-prevalence (5%) asymptomati
c populations produced a small benefit, which was lost if arteriograph
ic or surgical complications increased slightly. Arteriographic confir
mation of the US diagnosis of occlusion produced a small benefit only
in the symptomatic population. CONCLUSION: Screening symptomatic and h
igh-prevalence asymptomatic populations with US reduces stroke. Increa
sed arteriographic or surgical complication rates reduce the benefit o
f screening in any population.