T. Schaberg et al., RAPID DRUG SUSCEPTIBILITY TESTING OF MYCOBACTERIUM-TUBERCULOSIS USINGCONVENTIONAL SOLID MEDIA, The European respiratory journal, 8(10), 1995, pp. 1688-1693
Radiometric methods for M, tuberculosis drug susceptibility testing yi
eld much faster results than standard techniques; however, these metho
ds require sophisticated equipment and are expensive, We investigated
a rapid drug susceptibility testing method for isoniazid, rifampin, et
hambutol streptomycin and pyrazinamide in specimens from 197 patients
with pulmonary tuberculosis using a simplified agar-dilution method, M
iddlebrook 7H11 agar solid medium and microcolony detection were used
to test sputum from 64 smear-positive, and from 70 culture-positive bu
t smear-negative patients, Culture-positive material from bronchoscopy
, surgical biopsy, pleural fluid or gastric fluid of 63 patients was t
ested, In 64 smear-positive patients, the median time for final suscep
tibility results was 11 days (95% confidence interval(95% CI) 10-12 da
ys) compared to 62 days (95% CI 56-66 days) with the standard method,
In 133 smear-negative patients, results were available after a median
of 35 days (95% CI 32-40 days) in contrast to 72 days (95% CI 62-83 da
ys) with the standard method, regardless of whether or not sputum or o
ther materials were used for primary culture. The rapid method detecte
d all cases of single-drug resistance (n=20) and multidrug resistance
(n=14) within 13 days (95% CI 9-17 days) in smear-positive patients (n
=8), or within 38 days (95% CI 35-48 days) in smear-negative patients
(n=26), Only one discrepancy was encountered in 985 resistance tests,
Moreover, contamination was not observed, Our rapid susceptibility tes
ting method for M, tuberculosis on Middlebrook 7H11 agar is fast, prac
tical and inexpensive. It provides an alternative when more sophistica
ted techniques are not available or affordable.