Previous crystal-structure determination of magnesian annabergite (Ni,
Mg)(3)(AsO4)(2) . 8H(2)O indicated that ordering of Ni and Mg occurs i
n nonequivalent octahedral sites; such ordering supports the possibili
ty of miscibility gaps on the Ni-3(AsO4)(2) . 8H(2)O - Mg-3(AsO4)(2) .
8H(2)O (annabergite - hornesite) join. In a predecessor study based o
n compositions of natural specimens, it was proposed that solid soluti
on is incomplete both for annabergite - hornesite and annabergite - er
ythrite [Co-3(AsO4)(2) . 8H(2)O]. In the current study, syntheses by a
slow-addition technique at 70 and 95 degrees C indicated that the ann
abergite - erythrite solid solution is complete, that no miscibility g
ap is present on the annabergite - hornesite join to at least 58 mol%
Mg, and that no miscibility gap occurs on the erythrite - hornesite jo
in to at least 53 mol% Mg. Furthermore, no miscibility gaps are eviden
t in the low-Mg portion of the annabergite - erythrite - hornesite ter
nary system. Thus, interpretation of the compositions of these phases
in oxidized mill-tailings impoundments can be done with the normal pre
cautions for homogeneity, and without the added concern of the possibl
e presence of miscibility gaps in the ternary system.