The relation between characteristics of test takers and characteristic
s of items was examined in a quasi-experimental study. High-school sop
homores and juniors were administered a mathematics exam that was of c
onsequence to the sophomores but not the juniors. The juniors had more
mathematics course work as a group but less motivation to perform wel
l. Items were characterized by item difficulty (from p values), the de
gree to which they were mentally taxing (how much mental effort was ne
cessary to reach a correct answer), and item position (as an index of
the level of fatigue of the test taker). A differential item functioni
ng (DIF) analysis was conducted to look at differences between sophomo
res and juniors on an item-by-item basis. It was found that all three
item characteristic measures were related to the DIF index, with the m
ental taxation measure showing the strongest relation. Results are int
erpreted in relation to the expectancy value model of motivation as fo
rmulated by Pintrich (1988, 1989).