Ce. Schlekat et al., INTERLABORATORY COMPARISON OF A 10-DAY SEDIMENT TOXICITY TEST METHOD USING AMPELISCA-ABDITA, EOHAUSTORIUS-ESTUARIUS AND LEPTOCHEIRUS-PLUMULOSUS, Environmental toxicology and chemistry, 14(12), 1995, pp. 2163-2174
Estuarine and marine amphipods have been chosen by the U.S. Environmen
tal Protection Agency (EPA) for use in standardized 10-d sediment toxi
city tests. An interlaboratory comparison (round robin) was conducted
to evaluate the precision of these methods. This comparison included t
hree species, Ampelisca abdita, Eohaustorius estuarius, and Leptocheir
us plumulosus. Each species was exposed for 10 d under static, nonrene
wal conditions to four sediment treatments using standardized, species
-specific test protocols by at least six independent facilities. Sedim
ent treatments were selected for each species to include one negative
control sediment and three contaminated sediments. Highly contaminated
sediment from Black Rock Harbor (BRH), Connecticut, was diluted with
species-specific, noncontaminated control sediment, creating test sedi
ments that ranged in relative contamination from low to high. Laborato
ries showed strong, logical agreement in rank survival for all species
, with control sediment consistently exhibiting the highest survival,
and sediment with the greatest proportion of BRH consistently exhibiti
ng the lowest survival. Although instances of considerable interlabora
tory variability occurred, laboratories showed acceptable survival and
variability in control sediments, significant agreement in ranking se
diment toxicity, and agreement in the categorization of sediments as t
oxic or nontoxic for all three species.