Ye. Erdi et al., THRESHOLD ESTIMATION IN SINGLE-PHOTON EMISSION COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY AND PLANAR IMAGING FOR CLINICAL RADIOIMMUNOTHERAPY, Cancer research, 55(23), 1995, pp. 5823-5826
Thresholding is the most widely used organ or tumor segmentation techn
ique used in single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) and pl
anar imaging for monoclonal antibodies. Selecting the optimal threshol
d requires a priori knowledge (volumes from CT or magnetic resonance)
for the size and contrast level of the organ in question, Failure to s
elect an optimal threshold leads to overestimation or underestimation
of the volume and, subsequently, the organ-absorbed dose value in radi
oimmunotherapy. To investigate this threshold selection problem, we pe
rformed a phantom experiment using six lucite spheres ranging from 1 t
o 117 ml and filled with a uniform activity of 1 mu Ci/ml Tc-99m. Thes
e spheres were placed at the center and off-center locations of a Jasc
zsak phantom and scanned with a three-headed gamma camera in SPECT and
planar modes. Target:nontarget (T:NT) ratios were changed by adding t
he appropriate activity to the background. A threshold search algorith
m with an interpolative background correction was applied to sphere im
ages, This algorithm selects a threshold that minimizes the difference
between the true and measured volumes (SPECT) or areas (planar), It w
as found that for spheres equal to or larger than 20 ml [diameter (D)
> 38 mm] and T:NT ratios higher than 5:1, mean thresholds at 42% for S
PECT and 38% for planar imaging yielded minimum image segmentation err
ors, which is in agreement with current literature, However, for small
T:NT ratios (<5:1), the threshold values as high as 71% for SPECT and
85% for planar imaging were substantially different than those fixed
thresholds for large spheres (D > 38 mm), Hence, the use of fixed thre
sholds in low contrasts and with tumor and organ sizes of clinical int
erest (25 less than or equal to D less than or equal to 50 mm) may res
ult in limited volume estimation accuracy, Therefore, we have provided
the investigator a method to obtain the threshold values in which the
proper threshold can be selected based on the organ and tumor size an
d image contrast, By measuring and calibrating the proper threshold va
lue derived through machine-specific phantom measurements, a more accu
rate volume and activity quantitation can be performed. This, in turn,
will provide tumor-absorbed dose optimization and greater accuracy in
the measurement of potentially subacute, toxic absorbed doses to norm
al organs for patients undergoing radioimmunotherapy.