As part of our work on the influence of water source on reproductive o
utcome, Sprague-Dawley rats were randomized to tap water, bottled wate
r, or deionized water treatment groups, utilizing 160 animals per trea
tment; animals received the water prior to and during pregnancy, Rats
were shipped in four batches (A-D), Batch effects were seen for severa
l reproductive parameters, Because the tap water supply was interrupte
d by an earthquake resulting in an unbalanced design, primary analyses
utilized only batches C and D, which included most of the tap water-t
reated rats, A treatment effect with respect to resorption frequency w
as seen that was marginally significant using a fixed-effects analysis
of variance (P = 0.053), but not when batch was entered as a random e
ffect (P = 0.36), The data were modeled by logistic regression, contro
lling for batch, litter size, and batch-treatment interaction, The odd
s ratio comparing tap to bottled water was 1.8 (95% CI 1.0 to 3.3, P =
0,05), which was similar to the epidemiologic result that prompted th
is study, The magnitude of this association varied by batch, and the d
ifference in resorption frequency was within the range of variation se
en for control animals, Although these findings do not justify public
health action at this time, further investigation is warranted.