Hs. Wu et Mw. Wu, STUDY OF BALANCE-EQUATIONS FOR HOT-ELECTRON TRANSPORT IN AN ARBITRARYENERGY-BAND, Physica status solidi. b, Basic research, 192(1), 1995, pp. 129-143
In view of the recent disputes of Huang and Wu and Lei about Lei's bal
ance equation theory for an arbitrary energy band, the balance equatio
ns for hot-electron transport in an arbitrary energy band are reformul
ated. In the new formulation the adoption of the effective Hamiltonian
method is avoided and all calculations are carried out in laboratory
coordinates. In the mean time the crystal momentum k is carefully dist
inguished from the physical momentum. By introducing a correct equilib
rium density matrix of the drifting electron gas in place of that used
by Lei, the balance equations together with the distribution function
can be derived directly with no need to distinguish the degree of fre
edom of the center of mass from the relative degree of freedom of the
electrons, which is in our opinion neither possible nor necessary at l
east for a nonparabolic energy band. Some problems associated with the
foundation of the balance equation theory are also examined. The resu
lt shows that the comment to Lei's theory given by Huang and Wu is cor
rect and to the point. Nevertheless, contrary to their assertion that
this theory is inapplicable to the nonparabolic band transport, Lei's
balance equations, after a few, however, important corrections, are st
ill applicable to transport for nonparabolic energy bands.