Cl. Bean et al., CHROMOSOME-ABERRATIONS - PERSISTENCE OF ALKYLATION DAMAGE AND MODULATION BY O-6-ALKYLGUANINE-DNA ALKYLTRANSFERASE, MUTATION RESEARCH, 307(1), 1994, pp. 67-81
Alkylating agents produce a spectrum of DNA lesions alkylated at diffe
rent sites on the molecule. These lesions differ in their propensities
to cause effects such as cytotoxicity, mutations and sister-chromatid
exchanges. We have used our observations that some methylating agents
produce increasing levels of chromosome aberrations (abs) through suc
cessive cell cycles in Chinese hamster ovary cells, but not in normal
human cells, to begin a study of which alkylated products are most lik
ely to lead to chromosome abs, and in particular which adducts persist
in DNA and cause abs after the first cell cycle. We previously observ
ed increasing yields of abs with successive cell cycles in CHO-WBL cel
ls treated with dimethyl nitrosamine (DMN), e.g., at 10 mM DMN, 8.8% c
ells with abs at first metaphase (M1) and 26.0% at third metaphase (M3
) after treatment. Here we tested 4 methylating agents and their ethyl
analogs in CHO cells, normal human fibroblasts (L136), and human lymp
hocytes. We sampled cells at several times after treating for 3 h (CHO
and lymphocytes) or 4.5 h (L136). S9 metabolic activation was used fo
r DMN and diethyl nitrosamine. BrdUrd labeling was used to identify ce
lls in M1, M2 and M3. The methylating agents were more potent aberrati
on (ab) inducers than ethylating agents, on a molar basis. In CHO cell
s, yields of abs were maintained or increased through up to 3 cell cyc
les after treatment with DMN, methyl methanesulfonate, methyl nitrosou
rea and 1-methyr-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG). With ethylating ag
ents the ab yields in CHO cells were similar or lower in second and th
ird cycles. In contrast, there was no evidence for persistence of lesi
ons leading to abs in either human cell type; ab yields were markedly
decreased with subsequent cell cycles for all agents. Normal human cel
ls are proficient in repair of alkylation at the O-6 Site of guanine b
y O-6-alkylguanine-DNA arkyltransferase (AGT), whereas CHO cells lack
AGT activity. To explore the role of repair by AGT on the lesions invo
lved in production of abs, we studied L136 cells, with and without O-6
-benzylguanine (BZG), a specific inhibitor of AGT. With MNNG, inhibiti
on of AGT resulted in higher ab yield and production of abs through la
ter cell cycles, so that human fibroblasts now behaved similarly to CH
O cells. Preliminary data from the reciprocal experiment in CHO cells
engineered to express high levels of AGT revealed a greatly decreased
ab response to MNNG. In addition, the low ab yields observed were simi
lar through later cycles or increased only slightly. Although multiple
types of lesions and mechanisms of repair may be involved in ab produ
ction, O-6-methylguanine is an important lesion, particularly in secon
dary ab production in later cycles. The differences between CHO and no
rmal human cells in response to methylating agents may be due largely
to inherent levels of AGT.