The linear-transfer and lag-Manly models of zooplankton cohort develop
ment were examined using data generated from a third more realistic mo
del. The more realistic multi-transfer model included variance in deve
lopment rate among individuals. The linear-transfer model produced hig
hly biased estimates of development rate under conditions of rapidly c
hanging recruitment. Although its performance was improved by increasi
ng the number of modeled stages and thus decreasing the rate of change
in recruitment compared to stage duration, a positive bias remained.
The lag-Manly model also produced positively biased estimates of stage
duration given non zero variance in development rates. A comparison o
f the models' performances under different simulated sampling regimes
recommended the multi-transfer model. Use of the multi-transfer model
was illustrated by determining the development and mortality rates of
the brine shrimp, Artemia monica reared under three different conditio
ns of food and temperature corresponding to natural regimes in Mono La
ke, California. The experimental conditions and sampling regime result
ed in high relative standard errors (mean, 33%) in stage abundance est
imates not atypical of zooplankton sampling regimes in lakes. A Monte
Carlo analysis was used to determine the uncertainty in estimated para
meters and determine the level of stage aggregation which maximized th
e amount of information derived from the experiments.