More than a decade ago, observations of co-variance between VoverdotO(
2) and DoverdotO(2) led to the identification of a condition known as
pathological O-2 Supply dependency. This condition was subsequently ob
served in critically ill patients with sepsis and acute circulatory fa
ilure. More recently, other authors have challenged the existence of t
his condition, often citing methodological problems or mathematical co
upling to account for spurious observations in the earlier studies. He
re, we review the evidence for and against pathological O-2 supply dep
endency. We find that many of the arguments have some validity but onl
y in specific circumstances. We conclude, therefore, that pathological
O-2 supply dependency is a hallmark of acute circulatory failure and
that an effective therapeutic approach should be based on an evaluatio
n of organ system function in each individual case. Parameters such as
blood lactate, pHi and veno-arterial PCO2 may be useful in this respe
ct.