BACKGROUND: The enteral route is preferred in surgical patients requir
ing nutritional support; however, controversy surrounds the choice of
location of feeding tube placement. Although jejunostomy has been comm
only accepted as superior to gastrostomy for long-term nutritional sup
port because of an assumed lower risk of aspiration pneumonia, recent
studies suggest that reevaluation of common practices of surgical tube
placement is warranted. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We conducted a retrospe
ctive chart review of gastrostomy and jejunostomy procedures from 1986
to 1993. Demographic information and complications related to the pro
cedure were reviewed. Aspiration pneumonia was defined as respiratory
symptoms, leukocytosis, and infiltrate on chest radiograph. RESULTS: S
ixty-nine gastrostomies and 86 jejunostomies were performed during the
study period. Six patients were diagnosed with aspiration pneumonia;
2 cases of which occurred with jejunostomy and 4 cases occurred with g
astrostomy (P = not significant). CONCLUSIONS: There was no difference
in rates of pulmonary aspiration or other complications between gastr
ostomy and jejunostomy. We suggest that when a surgically placed feedi
ng tube is required, the determination of appropriate procedure be bas
ed on clinical factors such as the technical difficulty of the operati
on or long-term feeding goals.