Yd. Gao et al., MOLECULAR MECHANICS CALCULATION OF INNER-SHELL ACTIVATION BARRIERS TOHETEROGENEOUS ELECTRON-TRANSFER IN M(TACN)(2)(3+ 2+) REDOX COUPLES (M=FE, CO, NI, TACN=1,4,7-TRIAZACYCLONONANE)/, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 117(48), 1995, pp. 11932-11938
M(tacn)(2)(3+/2+) redox couples (M = Fe, Ni, Co; tacn = 1,4,7-triazacy
clononane) exhibit different extents of M-N bond lengthening upon elec
trochemical reduction and standard heterogeneous rate constants (k(s,h
)) that decrease systematically in accord with this structural feature
. Inner-shell enthalpies of activation (Delta H double dagger(is)) obt
ained from temperature-dependent measurements of k(s,h) [Crawford, P.
W,; Schultz, F. A. Inorg. Chem. 1991, 33, 4344] equal 1.7, 1.9, and 13
.2 kcal mol(-1) for M = Fe, Ni, and Co, respectively, in contrast with
values of 0.2, 2.2, and 6.0 kcal mol(-1) calculated by the harmonic o
scillator model of M-N bond elongation. In an attempt to resolve this
discrepancy we have carried out molecular mechanics calculation of Del
ta H double dagger(is) for M(tacn)(2)(3+/2+) couples using MMX and CHA
RMM force fields. The procedure for doing so involves intersecting pot
ential energy curves of oxidized and reduced reactants generated from
the force field parameters required to optimize the ground state struc
ture of each oxidation state. MMX barrier heights estimated in this wa
y are in close correspondence with the harmonic oscillator approximati
on widely used in Marcus theory calculation of inner-shell reorganizat
ion energies. The vibrational entropies of the molecules are calculate
d, and differences in these quantities correlate with the half-reactio
n entropy (Delta S degrees(rc)) of the M(tacn)(2)(3+/2+) couples. Non-
zero, metal-dependent values of Delta S degrees(rc) for these complexe
s are thought to arise from changes in M-N frequencies upon reduction
[Richardson, D. E.; Sharpe, P. Inorg. Chern, 1991, 30, 1412]. Poor cor
respondence between measured and calculated activation enthalpies rema
ins in cases where the electrode reaction exhibits a large half-reacti
on entropy. The molecular mechanics force fields are used to partition
the energy of the molecules into component terms, and it is found tha
t the majority of the inner-shell barrier derives from M-N bond stretc
hing.