A demonstrated period of abstinence is often viewed as a good prognost
ic sign in alcoholism. For example, short-term abstinence is one facto
r often considered important as a selection criteria for alcoholics wh
o are being evaluated as liver transplant candidates. However, the pro
gnostic validity of short-term abstinence is unclear. We evaluated the
effects of 3 and 6 months of abstinence on readmission rates in a ser
ies of 299 alcoholics following discharge from inpatient treatment. Re
admission rates were stratified using a 3-factor model of alcoholism s
everity. This 3-factor model defined groups with 1-year readmission ra
tes, ranging from 15.8% to 62.7%. Short-term abstinence did not have s
trong effects on readmission rates for the most severe alcoholics, nor
did short-term abstinence produce clinically significant reduction fo
r readmission rates for the least severe alcoholics. We conclude that
short-term abstinence has minimal effect on prognosis for alcoholics w
ith various levels of baseline severity.