Rv. Watkins et al., MEASURING CHILDRENS LEXICAL DIVERSITY - DIFFERENTIATING TYPICAL AND IMPAIRED LANGUAGE LEARNERS, Journal of speech and hearing research, 38(6), 1995, pp. 1349-1355
This study evaluated the extent to which measures of lexical diversity
(type-token ratio and number of different words produced) differentia
ted children with specific language impairment (SLI) from children who
se language skills were following typical developmental expectations.
Analysis of 50- and 100-utterance samples revealed that children with
SLI did not significantly differ from their age- and language-equivale
nt peers on type-token ratio; however, children with SLI did use signi
ficantly fewer different words than their age-equivalent peers in thes
e samples. When samples of 100 and 200 tokens were considered, the chi
ldren with SLI also-used significantly fewer different words than thei
r age-equivalent counterparts. Overall, the findings bf this study dis
courage the use of type-token ratio, as traditionally calculated, in m
any clinical and research activities related to children with SLI. In
contrast, the number of different words produced provides a more sensi
tive and informative estimate of lexical diversity.