Cs. Changchien et al., IS ERCP NECESSARY FOR SYMPTOMATIC GALLBLADDER STONE PATIENTS BEFORE LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY, The American journal of gastroenterology, 90(12), 1995, pp. 2124-2127
Objective: Laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) has become the choice of
treatment for symptomatic gallbladder stones. The goal of this study w
as to predict the necessity for ERCP before LC using the noninvasive m
ethod of liver function testing (LFT) and sonography. Methods: Before
LC, 115 symptomatic gallbladder stone patients, whose diagnoses were c
onfirmed by sonography, were studied by both LFT and ERCP. Patients wh
o were already found to have either turners or intrahepatic biliary st
ones on sonogram were excluded. Patients were classified into normal a
nd dilated biliary tree groups by sonographic findings and normal and
abnormal LFT (including bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, gamma glutamy
l transferase and amylase) groups. Results: In patients with both norm
al biliary sonogram and LFT, 97.6% of patients had a negative ERCP stu
dy. Biliary tree dilation on sonogram had an 87% positive predictabili
ty for ductal pathology on ERCP (40/46). A normal biliary tree on sono
gram had a 17.4% incidence of positive ductal pathology on ERCP (12/69
). A single abnormal LFT equated to a 68.8% positive predictability fo
r ductal pathology on ERCP. Conclusion: ERCP is not necessary before L
C for patients with symptomatic gallbladder stones who have both a nor
mal biliary tree on sonogram and normal LFT. A patient with either a d
ilated bile duct on sonogram or an abnormal liver function test does r
equire ERCP study.