The blunting line evaluation procedure used in the ESIS standard fract
ure toughness test method ''Procedure for Determining the Fracture Beh
aviour of Materials'' is re-evaluated to see if a simpler format can b
e developed. An equation based on the ultimate tensile strength was fo
und to represent the blunting line in a simple manner. This equation i
s in error at most +/-5% from the analytical representation and is as
accurate as the graphical procedure used to determine the blunting lin
e. It is recommended that this equation be used for fracture toughness
test standards which use the ESIS blunting line. A comparison of the
ESIS blunting line and the ASTM blunting line is made using some J-R c
urve data generated with an elastic unloading compliance test procedur
e. These data do not favor one line over the other. Microscopic evalua
tion of the blunting line reported in the literature using the stretch
zone width measured on the fracture surface suggests that the ESIS bl
unting line better represents the physical blunting process.