H. Ding et al., UBIQUINONE PAIR IN THE Q(O) SITE CENTRAL TO THE PRIMARY ENERGY-CONVERSION REACTIONS OF CYTOCHROME BC(1) COMPLEX, Biochemistry, 34(49), 1995, pp. 15979-15996
The mechanistic heart of the ubihydroquinone-cytochrome c oxidoreducta
se (cyt bet complex) is the catalytic oxidation of ubihydroquinone (QH
(2)) at the Q(o) site. QH(2) oxidation is initiated by ferri-cyt c, me
diated by the cyt c(1) and [2Fe-2S] cluster of the cytochrome bc(1) co
mplex. QH(2) oxidation in turn drives transmembrane electronic charge
separation through two b-type hemes to another ubiquinone (Q) at the Q
(i) site. In earlier studies, residues F144 and G158 of the b-heme con
taining polypeptide of the Rhodobacter capsulatus cyt bc(1) complex we
re shown to be influential in Q(o) site function. In the present study
, F144 and G158 have each been singly substituted by neutral residues
and the dissociation constants measured for both Q and QH(2) at each o
f the strong and weak binding Q(o) site domains (Q(os) and Q(ow)). Var
ious substitutions at F144 or G158 were found to weaken the affinities
for Q and QH(2) at both the Q(os) and Q(ow) domains variably from zer
o to beyond 10(3)-fold. This produced a family of Q(o) sites with Q(os
) and Q(ow) domain occupancies ranging from nearly full to nearly empt
y at the prevailing similar to 3 x 10(-2) M concentration of the membr
ane ubiquinone pool (Q(pool)). In each mutant, the affinity of the Q(o
s) domain remained typically 10-20-fold higher than that of the Q(ow)
domain, as is found for wild type, thereby indicating that the single
mutations caused comparable extents of the weakening at each domain. M
oreover, the substitutions were found to cause similar decreases of th
e affinities of both Q and QH(2) in each domain, thereby maintaining t
he Q/QH(2) redox midpoint potentials (E(m7)) of the Q(o) site at value
s similar to that of the wild type. Measurement of the yield and rate
of QH(2) oxidation generated by single turnover flashes in the family
of mutants suggests that the Q(os) and Q(ow) domains serve different r
oles for the catalytic process. The yield of the QH(2) oxidation corre
lates linearly with Q(os) domain occupancy (QH(2) or Q), suggesting th
at the Q(os) domain exchanges Q or QH(2) with the Q(pool) at a rate wh
ich is much slower than the time scale of turnover. On the other hand,
the rate constants of the first QH(2) oxidation, ranging in the mutan
ts from 1620 to <5 s(-1), correlate with the K-D values of QH(2) and Q
at the Q(ow) domain in a simple kinetic model in which the Q(ow) doma
in exchanges Q or QH(2) with the Q(pool) at a rate which is much faste
r than the time scale of turnover as constrained by the k(cat) (approx
imately 1700 s(-1)). The second QH(2) oxidation at the Q(o) site (requ
ired for completion of the catalytic turnover of the cyt bc(1) complex
) proceeds maximally at 350 s(-1) in the wild type, and the yield and
rate are affected by the single substitutions at F144 and G158 in para
llel to those of the first QH(2) oxidation. A plausible mechanism is p
resented in which the two ubiquinones of the Q(o) site cooperate in th
e primary steps of the catalytic action of the cyt bc(1) complex. Key
features of the mechanism are as follows: (1) The formation of ubisemi
quinone in both the Q(os) and Q(ow) domains is highly unfavorable. Thi
s keeps the steady-state concentration of the reactive semiquinone to
vanishingly low levels, and hence diminishes wasteful side reactions.
(2) The Q(os) and Q(ow) domains provide a conduit for the rapid moveme
nt of semiquinone away from the oxidizing side (the [2Fe-2S] cluster,
cyt c(1) and cyt c(2)) to reduce the cyt b(L). This process confers th
e directional specificity of the reaction, and minimizes the lifetime
of semiquinone and wasteful side reactions. (3) A linear arrangement o
f the ubiquinones in the Q(os) and Q(ow) domains allows the position o
f the cyt b(L) to be at a maximum distance from the [2Fe-2S] cluster a
nd thus stabilizes ferro-cyt b(L) with respect to the wasteful back-re
action from ferro-cyt b(L) to reoxidized [2Fe-2S] cluster. This strong
ly favors the physiologically useful electron transfer from ferro-cyt
b(L) to ferri-cyt b(H) and the Q in the Q(i) site.