Mh. Witte et al., KAPOSIS-SARCOMA, VASCULAR-PERMEABILITY, AND SCIENTIFIC INTEGRITY, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 271(22), 1994, pp. 1769-1771
On March 13, 1992, Nakamura et al published an article in the journal
Science reporting that sulfated polysaccharide peptidoglycan (SP-PG) i
nhibited the growth and vascular hyperpermeability characteristics of
Kaposi's sarcoma-related cells and lesions in nude mice. While examini
ng their key composite Fig 3, A through E, and related Table 2, we wer
e surprised by several photographic features and other irregularities
in the figures, which we explored further through a series of experime
nts. We were unable to confirm some of the pivotal findings. We commun
icated our concerns to Science but our letter was rejected. After subm
ission of additional analysis, the matter was reopened by Science, but
again our correspondence was rejected. Despite extensive review, the
salient points raised in our initial correspondence remain unanswered
or only tangentially addressed. The original conclusions by Nakamura e
t al are still not only highly dubious, but the validity of the peer r
eview process and self-correcting nature of scientific inquiry are als
o called into question.