Ca. Scholin et al., MOLECULAR EVOLUTION OF THE ALEXANDRIUM-TAMARENSE SPECIES COMPLEX (DINOPHYCEAE) - DISPERSAL IN THE NORTH-AMERICAN AND WEST PACIFIC REGIONS, Phycologia, 34(6), 1995, pp. 472-485
Hypotheses concerning the molecular evolution, population structure an
d dispersal of the toxic dinoflagellates Alexandrium tamarense (Lebour
) Balech, A. catenella (Whedon et Kofoid) Balech and A. fundyense Bale
ch (the 'tanarensis species complex') are examined in light of previou
s reports that compared their small and large-subunit ribosomal RNA ge
nt: (SSU and LSU rDNA) sequences. Forty-eight cultures from North Amer
ica, western Europe. Japan: Australia and Thailand were analysed by a
restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) assay of SSU rDNA. and
34 of those by sequencing a fragment of LSU rDNA. Results indicate th
at the tamarensis species complex comprises at least 5 genetically dis
tinct evolutionary lineages ('ribotypes') whose phylogenetic relations
hips reflect geographic populations, not morphospecies. We believe thi
s pattern reveals a monophyletic radiation from an ancestor that inclu
ded or gave rise to multiple morphotypes. Accumulated mutations in des
cendants' SSU and LSU rDNA are suggested to reflect the prolonged geog
raphic isolation and independent evolution of distinct populations. No
vel SSU rDNA data are presented in support of this hypothesis. Given t
he proposed evolutionary framework and other historical considerations
, we interpret the genetic diversity of Japanese A. tamarense/catenell
a as indicative of dispersed populations from genetically distinct sou
rces. The possibility that A. catenella was introduced to Australia fr
om an Asian source is also considered. In both cases, however, rDNA da
ta alone are insufficient to distinguish whether this occurred thousan
ds of years ago by natural immigrations or as a result of recent human
activity (ballast water transport or relays of shellfish stocks). The
uncertainty of dispersal timing stems from the relatively slow rate a
t which rDNA evolves and lack of fossil evidence. Ballast water sample
s show that viable toxigenic Alexandrium cysts have undergone human-as
sisted transoceanic transport, illustrating how a region could be 'see
ded' with genetically distinct A. tamarense and A. catenella from a va
riety of regional populations.