J. Ghosh et al., CERAMIC BRACKET DESIGN - AN ANALYSIS USING THE FINITE-ELEMENT METHOD, American journal of orthodontics and dentofacial orthopedics, 108(6), 1995, pp. 575-582
This investigation was designed to generate finite element models for
selected ceramic brackets and graphically display the stress distribut
ion in the brackets when subjected to arch wire torsion and tipping fo
rces. Six commercially available ceramic brackets, one monocrystalline
and five polycrystalline alumina, of twin bracket design for the perm
anent maxillary left central incisor were studied. Three-dimensional c
omputer models of the brackets were constructed and loading forces, si
milar to those applied by a full-size (0.0215 x 0.028 inch) stainless
steel arch wire in torsion and tipping necessary to fracture ceramic b
rackets, were applied to the models. Stress levels were recorded at re
levant points common among the various brackets. High stress levels we
re observed at areas of abrupt change in geometry and shape. The desig
n of the wire slot and wings for the Contour bracket (Class One Orthod
ontic Products, Lubbock, Texas) and of the outer edges of the wire slo
t for the Allure bracket (GAG, Central Islip, N.Y.) were found to be g
ood in terms of even stress distribution. The brackets with an isthmus
connecting the wings seemed to resist stresses better than the one br
acket that did not have this feature. The design of the isthmus for th
e Transcend (Unitek/3M, Monrovia, Calif.) and Lumina (Ormco, Glendora,
Calif.) brackets were found to be acceptable as well. The Starfire br
acket (''A'' Company, San Diego, Calif.) showed high stresses and irre
gular stress distribution, because it had sharp angles, no rounded cor
ners, and no isthmus. The finite element method proved to be a useful
tool in the stress analysis of ceramic orthodontic brackets subjected
to various forces. This analysis provides key information to the devel
opment of an optimum bracket design.