Systematic studies of flux pinning in YBa2Cu3O7-delta single crystals
have been undertaken in an attempt to isolate the mechanisms that may
cause the so-called fishtail pinning effect, a rise in critical curren
t density (J(c)) that occurs as the magnetic field (H) increases. Two
different sources of point defect pinning, 200 MeV proton irradiation
and oxygen annealing, are used to alter the system and to determine ho
w each one changes the J(c) vs H curves. The fishtail pinning effect i
s extremely robust and survives both in magnitude and with a similar s
lope of the J(c) vs H curve for a wide range of irradiation and for wi
de excursions in oxygen content and annealing condition. The data are
consistent with an intrinsic granularity arising from cation disorder
that survives as oxygen is inserted and removed and as irradiation ind
uced point defects are added and removed.