P. Cloke et al., DEPRIVATION, POVERTY AND MARGINALIZATION IN RURAL LIFE-STYLES IN ENGLAND AND WALES, Journal of rural studies, 11(4), 1995, pp. 351-365
Research studies of the problems of rural life in Britain have often b
een based on concepts such as 'deprivation' or 'disadvantage'. In this
paper we explore the basis of these conceptualizations and note claim
s that they have been appropriated by government at local and central
levels, suggesting that criticism of such appropriation should not lea
d to a neglect of material privation of opportunities caused by change
s to the structure of rural life, brought about by economic restructur
ing, social recomposition and the political-economy of deregulation. R
ather, we draw on studies of rural poverty to suggest that the changin
g material base of rural life has been accompanied by a range of discu
rsive strategies which obscure rural problems and even filter them out
altogether in the various constructions of idyll-ized rural life as t
he spatial expression of self-supporting, self-sufficient, happy, heal
thy and problem-free existence in a market place economy. Using some o
f the findings from the Rural Lifestyles research programme in England
and Wales we discuss some of the different experiences of opportunity
privation in rural areas, and some of the different ways in which cul
tural constructions of rural life can lead to a range of expectations
from imagined rural geographies which are variously met and not met in
day-to-day rural lifestyles. We suggest that rural problems are assoc
iated with a wide range of experiences of marginalization - economic,
political, social, cultural - which cannot be mapped out according to
normative or cultural expectations, but which occur differently at the
intersection of material and experiential elements of rural lifestyle
s.