R. Launois, INTEGRATING INDIVIDUAL PREFERENCES INTO T HERAPEUTIC AND COLLECTIVE CHOICES, Revue d'epidemiologie et de sante publique, 42(3), 1994, pp. 246-262
The objectives of contemporary medecine are basically to attenuate the
consequences of chronic diseases and to improve the quality of life o
f the patient. All medical disciplines tend now to elicit therapeutic
protocols directly from the general appreciation of the patients. The
community is trying to obtain a transnosographic indicator which would
allow the effects of its strategic choices between different areas of
the health care system to be measured, taking into account the implic
ations on the quality of life of the population. Individual preference
s are now at the center of the decision-making process. Different expe
rimental methods are beeing used to reveal them. Psychometricians use
direct observation of a subject's reactions in a particular pathologic
al situation : patients are asked to arrange the intensity of the impa
cts on bipolar numeric scales, but an actual metrical measure is not y
et available. Traditionally, economists believe that in a market, only
the consumer's choices enable us to estimate his level of satisfactio
n. In the health care field, where market mechanisms are not fully ope
rational, they tend to extract the patients preferences through forced
choices between hypothetical health states. A real metrical measure i
s thus obtained The objective of this article is to exhibit these two
methods : psychometric and economic, and to show how they have been im
plemented in French field research to obtain quality adjusted life yea
rs indicators : QALY's.