Objective: Although depression frequently occurs in multiple sclerosis
(MS), an association with cerebral pathology is unclear. This sets MS
apart from other common neurological disorders. The reasons for this
are explored. Method: The literature on depression and magnetic resona
nce imaging (MRT) is reviewed and methodological issues are critically
evaluated. Results: Failure to demonstrate cerebral correlates of dep
ression is in part a function of poor study design. However, the diffu
se nature of cerebral demyelination creates difficulties in image anal
ysis peculiar to MS. Conclusions: More research using valid psychiatri
c assessment procedures, high field strength MRI and automated lesion
detection is needed to resolve the issue. It is premature to reject ps
ychosocial causes at this stage.