Purposes: To identify clinical variables prognostic for prompt excisio
n of melanocytic iris tumors and to determine the clinical factors pre
dictive of enlargement of those tumors managed initially by observatio
n. Methods: A retrospective study of 285 patients evaluated in a refer
ral center over a 15-year interval (1972-1986). Results: Thirty-six le
sions were excised promptly, whereas 249 were observed. Eighty-nine pe
rcent of the 36 promptly excised tumors were malignant melanomas on hi
stopathologic examination. Five clinical variables were associated str
ongly with prompt excision: largest basal tumor diameter greater than
3 mm; presence of pigment dispersion; prominent tumor vascularity; ele
vated intraocular pressure; and tumor-related ocular symptoms. In the
observed group, the actuarial 5-year rate of lesion enlargement was 6.
5% (standard error = 2.1%). Of the ten lesions that enlarged, six were
excised and evaluated histopathologically. Five of these six lesions
were malignant melanomas on histopathologic study. Largest basal tumor
diameter was the only clinical variable strongly predictive of lesion
enlargement. Only two patients died of metastatic uveal melanoma, and
both were in the promptly treated group. Conclusions: Most melanocyti
c iris tumors are benign and do not enlarge appreciably when followed
or lead to metastatic disease. However, even prompt locally effective
treatment (excision) is insufficient to prevent metastasis in some pat
ients. Clinical features of the iris lesion appear to enable clinician
s to differentiate reasonably well between probable malignant melanoma
s, for which prompt treatment seems appropriate, and benign nevi, for
which observation with periodic follow-up is likely to be the best man
agement.