B. Saletu et al., DOUBLE-BLIND, PLACEBO-CONTROLLED, HORMONAL, SYNDROMAL AND EEG MAPPINGSTUDIES WITH TRANSDERMAL ESTRADIOL THERAPY IN MENOPAUSAL DEPRESSION, Psychopharmacology, 122(4), 1995, pp. 321-329
In a double-blind, placebo-controlled study, the antidepressant and vi
gilance-promoting properties of transdermal oestrogen in post-menopaus
al depression were investigated utilizing hormonal, syndromal and EEC
mapping evaluations. Sixty-nine menopausal women, aged 45-60 years wit
hout previous hormonal replacement therapy, diagnosed as major depress
ion without psychotic or suicidal symptoms (DSM-III-R criteria), were
randomly assigned to a 3-month treatment with transdermal oestradiol [
Estraderm TTS (ETTS) 50 mu g, applied twice weekly] or placebo. No oth
er psychoactive medication was allowed. After removal of protocol viol
ators, 32 patients were evaluable in each group, which did not differ
in age, height or weight. As five patients discontinued prematurely in
both groups and in one placebo patient a post-drug EEG could not be o
btained, 27 patients remained in the ETTS and 26 in the placebo group
for efficacy analysis. While in the placebo group, oestradiol (E2) and
follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) remained unchanged, E2 increased a
nd FSH decreased significantly in the ETTS group. Syndromal evaluation
showed a significant improvement in the Kupperman Index (KI) as well
as Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAMD) in both groups, with no int
er-group difference. However, EEG mapping demonstrated significant int
er-drug differences in brain function, mostly over the left temporal r
egion. While ETTS patients showed an in crease of alpha and alpha-adja
cent theta activity and a decrease of beta activity, as well as an acc
eleration of the delta/theta centroid and a slowing of the alpha, beta
and total power centroid, no changes occurred in the placebo-treated
patients. These neurophysiological findings suggestimprovement of vigi
lance by oestrogen, previously referred to as ''mental tonic'' effect.
There were no changes, however, in the frontal alpha asymmetry index,
reflecting left frontal hypo- and right frontal hyperactivation. Thus
, this neurophysiological variable represents a state-independent mark
er for depression. The tolerability of ETTS was very good.