The biological definition oi family at the root of functionalist kinsh
ip theory has been rightly criticized by contemporary feminist and sym
bolic anthropologists, but in retreating into an antinatural position
such critiques simply recapitulate the limitations of an opposition be
tween nature and culture in which the former is prior and essential, t
he latter secondary and historical. From the perspective of Zumbagua,
where people become parents by feeding and caring for children over ex
tended periods of time, both schools of thought are not only inadequat
e to explain fully the material bases of local practice but are repres
entative of a specific Western-bourgeois ideology that indigenous peop
le actively oppose.