Ch. Kiang et al., CATALYTIC EFFECTS OF HEAVY-METALS ON THE GROWTH OF CARBON NANOTUBES AND NANOPARTICLES, Journal of physics and chemistry of solids, 57(1), 1996, pp. 35-39
The effects of bismuth, lead, and tungsten on the cobalt-catalyzed syn
thesis of single-layer carbon nanotubes and nanoparticles have been st
udied. When co-vaporized with cobalt in an electric are, bismuth and l
ead increase the yield of single-layer nanotubes and broaden the range
of tube diameters, compared to the case where only cobalt is used. Tu
ngsten is found to reduce the nanotube yield and does not change the t
ube diameter distribution. Both tungsten and bismuth increase the grap
hitization of the carbon encapsulating the cobalt particles found in t
he soot, while lead does not. None of these three heavy metals catalyz
es the formation of single-layer nanotubes without a transition metal
present.